Is Laconica a more sustainable Twitter?

Identica logo.pngLaconica? Huh? Did you just ask me that? Well, if you don’t know what Laconica is, perhaps you know what Identi.ca is? For those who are oblivious, Identi.ca is the fairly well hyped open source version of Twitter … in a sense (if you don’t know what Twitter is, move right along). Laconica is the name of the software that Identi.ca runs on together with a host of other services that work very similarly. For the most part a discussion about Identi.ca on the local blogosphere has been focussed on Identi.ca as a Twitter replacement and the inevitable question why anyone would want to switch to Identi.ca/any other microblogging service when, sing along with me, everyone is on Twitter?

If you consider any Laconica service as a straight Twitter replacement then it can be a little difficult to make the switch if your focus is sticking with the rest of the crowd. What you may not realise is that these Laconica sites are not endeavouring to become the next Twitter individually. Heck, even collectively they are not necessarily looking to replace Twitter. Part of the appeal of having an open source platform like Laconica is to be able to create smaller community focussed microblogging services. A very good example of this is the TWiT Army microblogging site which runs on Laconica. Leo Laporte established the TWiT Army site after an interview with Evan Prodromou, one of the creators (or the creator?) of Laconica with the intention of establishing a microblogging service focussed on the TWiT network ands its army of fans. In other words, he created a niche microblogging service.

What came out of that interview was a fascinating possibility. If you use a Laconica-based service like Identi.ca (I am pauljacobson on Identi.ca) you can connect to and follow people using other Laconica-based services. Although the idea isn’t quite to establish a Twitter replacement (although Evan mention there may be a consolidated stream for people who want one and that would be comparable to a general Twitter stream), the power of the Laconica model is that the sites are distributed. You can install Laconica on your own server and run your own microblogging service. Each Laconica service interoperates with the others (they run the same software and use open standards to communicate).

The software is open source and released under the GNU Affero General Public License. That means you can pretty much use it freely provided you comply with the terms of the license. Because the overall system is distributed the whole thing can presumably cope with the kinds of loads Twitter is dealing with easier (any developers want to chime in and correct or support me?). Laconica also runs on PHP which is apparently a good thing too.

Twitter, on the other hand, is a centralised service running on a platform that can’t sustain the number of users using that service. Granted Twitter is getting better at managing the load, it still has outages that frustrate users to no end even though they keep returning. Perhaps an open source, distributed and interoperable system is better than a centralised platform in the long run?


Technorati Tags:
, , , ,

Paul

Enthusiast, writer, strategist, web developer, and photographer. Passionate about my wife, Gina and #proudDad.

21 Comments

  1. Great read Paul. I joined the twit army the second that Leo had it up. It makes more sense to be a part of a community that is geared towards a common interest. (i did see one small type/grammar correction … last paragraph… “still have” should be “still has”)I'll be adding your feed to my regularly checked blogs list.Cheers,Chris

  2. Great read Paul. I joined the twit army the second that Leo had it up. It makes more sense to be a part of a community that is geared towards a common interest.

    (i did see one small type/grammar correction … last paragraph… “still have” should be “still has”)

    I'll be adding your feed to my regularly checked blogs list.

    Cheers,
    Chris

  3. Great read Paul. I joined the twit army the second that Leo had it up. It makes more sense to be a part of a community that is geared towards a common interest.

    (i did see one small type/grammar correction … last paragraph… “still have” should be “still has”)

    I'll be adding your feed to my regularly checked blogs list.

    Cheers,
    Chris

  4. Hey ChrisThanks for the comment and the correction. I have fixed the error.I'd like to see Laconica adopted more widely. Hopefully the overwhelming gravitational forces Twitter exerts will not crush all resistance just yet although I think Steve Gillmor is probably right about Twitter's continued dominance (take a look at his post at http://www.techcrunchit.com/2008/09/01/why-twit…).

  5. Hey Chris

    Thanks for the comment and the correction. I have fixed the error.

    I'd like to see Laconica adopted more widely. Hopefully the overwhelming gravitational forces Twitter exerts will not crush all resistance just yet although I think Steve Gillmor is probably right about Twitter's continued dominance (take a look at his post at http://www.techcrunchit.com/2008/09/01/why-twit…).

  6. Hey Chris

    Thanks for the comment and the correction. I have fixed the error.

    I'd like to see Laconica adopted more widely. Hopefully the overwhelming gravitational forces Twitter exerts will not crush all resistance just yet although I think Steve Gillmor is probably right about Twitter's continued dominance (take a look at his post at http://www.techcrunchit.com/2008/09/01/why-twit…).

  7. yeah, I saw and read that the other day… and I don't really have a problem with twitter staying as king of the hill, but do agree with him and dave wiener on the importance of alternatives, and more importantly getting the public feed in real-time.i really enjoy the track functionality that i can get over the twit army and identica all through a jabber client (usually gmail chat)also of note, i do also enjoy using twitterspy via instant messaging as well… much more convenient than doing searches all the time.

  8. yeah, I saw and read that the other day… and I don't really have a problem with twitter staying as king of the hill, but do agree with him and dave wiener on the importance of alternatives, and more importantly getting the public feed in real-time.

    i really enjoy the track functionality that i can get over the twit army and identica all through a jabber client (usually gmail chat)

    also of note, i do also enjoy using twitterspy via instant messaging as well… much more convenient than doing searches all the time.

  9. yeah, I saw and read that the other day… and I don't really have a problem with twitter staying as king of the hill, but do agree with him and dave wiener on the importance of alternatives, and more importantly getting the public feed in real-time.

    i really enjoy the track functionality that i can get over the twit army and identica all through a jabber client (usually gmail chat)

    also of note, i do also enjoy using twitterspy via instant messaging as well… much more convenient than doing searches all the time.

    edit: i swear this was in reply… but oh well…

  10. out of curiosity… how's disqus going for you?

    i'm seriously thinking about switching over to it for my blog…
    is it super easy? do i have anything to take into consideration?

    also wondering about your thoughts on this subject now that some time has passed?
    have you blogged anything recently you'd like to point me towards?

    cheers

  11. Hey Chris

    It is going well for me. I definitely prefer this form of interaction over the built in commenting functionality. I do have IntenseDebate running on another blog and there are aspects of that service that appeal to me (I like the OpenID integration for one thing) but I don't have many comments on there to be able to assess its functionality compared to Disqus.

    I would like to see more options on the backend of Disqus but I was told that an improved backend is in the works for Disqus so I am happy with my choice. I do like the fact that if I remove Disqus all the comments I have received remain in the blog (I didn't know that when I installed Disqus) so there is really no harm in trying it out.

  12. N97 is one of the best phones I have ever come across, I am fortunate enough to have it with me from one week!

What do you think?

%d bloggers like this: