Sometimes democracy isn’t such a good thing

If anything the ANC leadership race is a good illustration of where democracy can be more harmful than beneficial.  Take a party with a huge majority in parliament, throw in a leadership race between an incumbent who hasn’t fulfilled his potential and a disgraced challenger who has tremendous popular support and we have a receipe for disaster and there is nothing we can do to stop it.  All we really can do is what it happen, like watching an accident about to occur.

Zuma is appealing to the lowest common denominator with old Struggle songs and just about whatever else they want to hear.  He talks about revisiting the death penalty, being tough on crime, friendly to business and just about anything any possible group of supporters want to hear.  What I don’t see is any sort of set of principles.  He is a political mercenary and he is only becoming more and more popular.  Things in the ANC seem to have reached a point where there is no tolerance for opposing views (or any views other than wholesale and fanatical support for Zuma) and senior members of the party are shouted down or boo’ed off the stage.

There has been talk about unifying forces in the ANC and possible 3rd candidates but I think this is wishful thinking.  The ANC has come to be ruled by populist candidates who promise everything to everyone and stand for nothing of any substance.  Barring some sort of miracle in Polokwane later today, we can expect to see Zuma emerge as president of the ANC and possible president of the country when Mbeki leaves office.  Our only hope for some semblance of sanity is to see Zuma successfully charged and convicted very soon although the chances of that happening are debatable.

Nevermind the ANC going to the dogs, the ANC is poised to take the rest of the country down with it and all we can do is watch it happen.

Update:  On the lighter side you really should read Ndumiso Ngcobo’s post on Thought Leader titled "A blogger in Polokwane … an experiment gone wrong".  As Matthew Buckland promised, it is hilarious.  I can’t believe the President actually read his 42 page report for 2 and a half hours even though everyone had a copy.  No wonder he is on his way out the door.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Comments

  1. Vincent Maher avatar

    Paul this post is downright insulting to the working class electorate in this country.

  2. Paul avatar

    Vince, sometimes there is no accounting for the working class electorate's choice in leadership …

  3. Vincent Maher avatar

    There is plenty of accounting for it when you consider that for many the ANC has not delivered any substantial difference to their lives over the past ten years.

  4. Paul avatar

    I wasn't referring to the incumbent leadership. There is no excuse why the country hasn't been developed far beyond the point it is at now by the current leadership. That is still no reason to introduce a possible president whose election to the highest office of this land could well spell dark days for this country and even less development for those who support him.

    This country needs new and inspired leadership not someone who loyally tows the party line, whichever party that may be.

  5. Vincent Maher avatar

    Paul this post is downright insulting to the working class electorate in this country.

  6. Vincent Maher avatar

    Paul this post is downright insulting to the working class electorate in this country.

  7. Vincent Maher avatar

    Paul this post is downright insulting to the working class electorate in this country.

  8. Paul avatar

    Vince, sometimes there is no accounting for the working class electorate’s choice in leadership …

  9. Paul avatar

    Vince, sometimes there is no accounting for the working class electorate’s choice in leadership …

  10. Paul avatar

    Vince, sometimes there is no accounting for the working class electorate’s choice in leadership …

  11. Vincent Maher avatar

    There is plenty of accounting for it when you consider that for many the ANC has not delivered any substantial difference to their lives over the past ten years.

  12. Vincent Maher avatar

    There is plenty of accounting for it when you consider that for many the ANC has not delivered any substantial difference to their lives over the past ten years.

  13. Vincent Maher avatar

    There is plenty of accounting for it when you consider that for many the ANC has not delivered any substantial difference to their lives over the past ten years.

  14. Paul avatar

    I wasn’t referring to the incumbent leadership. There is no excuse why the country hasn’t been developed far beyond the point it is at now by the current leadership. That is still no reason to introduce a possible president whose election to the highest office of this land could well spell dark days for this country and even less development for those who support him.

    This country needs new and inspired leadership not someone who loyally tows the party line, whichever party that may be.

  15. Paul avatar

    I wasn’t referring to the incumbent leadership. There is no excuse why the country hasn’t been developed far beyond the point it is at now by the current leadership. That is still no reason to introduce a possible president whose election to the highest office of this land could well spell dark days for this country and even less development for those who support him.

    This country needs new and inspired leadership not someone who loyally tows the party line, whichever party that may be.

  16. Paul avatar

    I wasn’t referring to the incumbent leadership. There is no excuse why the country hasn’t been developed far beyond the point it is at now by the current leadership. That is still no reason to introduce a possible president whose election to the highest office of this land could well spell dark days for this country and even less development for those who support him.

    This country needs new and inspired leadership not someone who loyally tows the party line, whichever party that may be.

  17. matt avatar

    hmmm… have to agree with Vincent on this one. In fact — be careful because this is the exact line of argument the Apartheid regime followed… and I am sure you don't mean to be in that camp. Here's another, more optimistic take on proceedings by Stephen Friedman: http://www.thoughtleader.co.za/stevenfriedman/2007/12/17/no-dear-thats-not-mob-rule-its-called-democracy/“>http://www.thoughtleader.co.za/stevenfriedman/2

  18. matt avatar

    hmmm… have to agree with Vincent on this one. In fact — be careful because this is the exact line of argument the Apartheid regime followed… and I am sure you don’t mean to be in that camp. Here’s another, more optimistic take on proceedings by Stephen Friedman: http://www.thoughtleader.co.za/stevenfriedman/2007/12/17/no-dear-thats-not-mob-rule-its-called-democracy/

  19. matt avatar

    hmmm… have to agree with Vincent on this one. In fact — be careful because this is the exact line of argument the Apartheid regime followed… and I am sure you don’t mean to be in that camp. Here’s another, more optimistic take on proceedings by Stephen Friedman: http://www.thoughtleader.co.za/stevenfriedman/2007/12/17/no-dear-thats-not-mob-rule-its-called-democracy/

  20. matt avatar

    hmmm… have to agree with Vincent on this one. In fact — be careful because this is the exact line of argument the Apartheid regime followed… and I am sure you don’t mean to be in that camp. Here’s another, more optimistic take on proceedings by Stephen Friedman: http://www.thoughtleader.co.za/stevenfriedman/2007/12/17/no-dear-thats-not-mob-rule-its-called-democracy/

  21. Populist democracy has failed avatar

    […] Buckland suggested my rant about democracy the other day was the same argument made by the Apartheid regime.  He also […]

What do you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.